Cost Efficiency and Total Factor Productivity: An Empirical Analysis of Pakistan’s Insurance Sector
Keywords:
Data envelopment analysis, efficiency, productivity, Malmquist index.Abstract
This study uses data envelopment analysis and the Malmquist index to examine the impact of financial sector reforms on the efficiency and productivity of Pakistan’s insurance sector over the period 2000–09. Our results indicate that the sector is cost-inefficient, with an average score of 58 percent – an outcome of the inappropriate use of inputs. The Malmquist productivity index performs better, indicating an improvement in total factor productivity of about 3 percent on average. The second-stage Tobit regression analysis shows that large firms are relatively inefficient from an allocative perspective as they are unable to equate the marginal product of inputs with their factor prices. Furthermore, the results demonstrate that private firms are more efficient than public firms in the nonlife insurance sector. The empirical findings suggest that a more competitive environment, diversified products and innovative technology could improve the productivity of insurance firms in Pakistan.
References
Ali, A. I., & Seiford, L. M. (1993). The mathematical programming approach to efficiency analysis. In H. O. Fried, C. A. Knox Lovell & S. S. Schmidt (Eds.), The measurement of productive efficiency: Techniques and applications (pp. 20–59). New York: Oxford University Press.
Amel, D., Barnes, C., Panetta, F., & Salleo, C. (2004). Consolidation and efficiency in the financial sector: A review of the international evidence. Journal of Banking and Finance, 28(10), 2493–2519.
Berger, A. N., & Humphrey, D. B. (1997). Efficiency of financial institutions: international survey and directions for future research. European Journal of Operational Research, 98(2), 175–212.
Bernstein, J. I. (1999). Total factor productivity growth in the Canadian life insurance industry: 1979–1989. Canadian Journal of Economics, 32(2), 500–517.
Bikker, J. A., & van Leuvensteijn, M. (2008). Competition and efficiency in the Dutch life insurance industry. Applied Economics, 40, 2063–2084.
Burki, A. A., & Ahmad, S. (2010). Bank governance changes in Pakistan: Is there a performance effect? Journal of Economics and Business, 62(2), 129–146.
Burki, A. A., & Niazi, G. S. K. (2006). Impact of financial reforms on efficiency of state-owned, private and foreign banks in Pakistan (CMER Working Paper No. 06-49). Lahore: Lahore University of Management Sciences.
Caves, D., Christensen, L., & Diewert, W. (1982). The economic theory of index numbers and the measurement of input, output and productivity. Econometrica, 50(6), 1393–1414.
Coelli, T. (1996). A guide to DEAP version 2.1: A data envelopment analysis (computer) program (CEPA Working Paper No. 96/08). Armidale, NSW: University of New England.
Cummins, J. D., & Nini, G. (2002). Optimal capital utilization by financial firms: Evidence from the property-liability insurance industry. Journal of Financial Services Research, 21(1), 15–53.
Cummins, J. D., & Rubio-Misas, M. (2006). Deregulation, consolidation and efficiency: Evidence from the Spanish insurance industry. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 38(2), 323–355.
Cummins, J. D., & Weiss, M. A. (1993). Measuring cost efficiency in the property-liability insurance industry. Journal of Banking and Finance, 17(2–3), 463–481.
Cummins, J. D., & Weiss, M. A. (1998). Analyzing firm performance in the insurance industry using frontier efficiency methods (Working Paper No. 98-22). Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania, Wharton Financial Institutions Center.
Cummins, J. D., & Xie, X. (2008). Mergers and acquisitions in the US property-liability insurance industry: Productivity and efficiency effects. Journal of Banking and Finance, 32(1), 30–55.
Cummins, J. D., & Zi, H. (1998). Comparison of frontier efficiency methods: An application to the US life insurance industry. Journal of Productivity Analysis, 10(2), 131–152.
Cummins, J. D., Tennyson, S., & Weiss M. A. (1999). Consolidation and efficiency in the US life insurance industry. Journal of Banking and Finance, 23(2–4), 325–357.
Cummins, J. D., Turchetti, G., & Weiss, M. A. (1996). Productivity and technical efficiency in the Italian insurance industry (Working Paper No. 96-10). Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania, Wharton Financial Institutions Center.
Cummins, J. D., Weiss, M. A., & Zi, H. (1999). Organizational form and efficiency: The coexistence of stock and mutual property-liability insurers. Management Science, 45, 1254–1269.
Diacon, S. R., Starkey, K., & O’Brien, C. (2002). Size and efficiency in European long-term insurance companies: An international comparison. The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance, 27(3), 444–466.
di Patti, E. B., & Hardy, D. C. (2005). Financial sector liberalization, bank privatization and efficiency: Evidence from Pakistan. Journal of Banking and Finance, 29(8–9), 2381–2406.
Eling, M., & Luhnen, M. (2010a). Efficiency in the international insurance industry: A cross-country comparison. Journal of Banking and Finance, 34(7), 1497–1509.
Eling, M., & Luhnen, M. (2010b). Frontier efficiency methodologies to measure performance in the insurance industry: Overview, systematization and recent developments. The Geneva Papers, 35, 217–265.
Fare, R., Grosskopf, S., Norris, M., & Zhang, Z. (1994). Productivity growth, technical progress, and efficiency change in industrialized countries. American Economic Review, 84(1), 66–83.
Farrell, M. J. (1957). The measurement of productive efficiency. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A (General), 120(3), 253–290.
Fenn, P., Vencappa, D., Diacon, S., Klumpes, P., & O’Brien, C. (2008). Market structure and the efficiency of European insurance companies: A stochastic frontier analysis. Journal of Banking and Finance, 32(1), 86–100.
Fukuyama, H. (1997). Investigating productive efficiency and productivity changes of Japanese life insurance companies. Pacific-Basin Finance Journal, 5(4), 481–509.
Gardner, L. A., & Grace, M. F. (1993). X-efficiency in the US life insurance industry. Journal of Banking and Finance, 17(2–3), 497–510.
Greene, W. H., & Segal, D. (2004). Profitability and efficiency in the US life insurance industry. Journal of Productivity Analysis, 21, 229–247.
Hao, J. C. J., & Chou, L.-Y. (2005). The estimation of efficiency for life insurance industry: The case in Taiwan. Journal of Asian Economics, 16(5), 847–860.
Hardwick, P. (1997). Measuring cost inefficiency in the UK life insurance industry. Applied Financial Economics, 7(1), 37–44.
Insurance Association of Pakistan. (2008). Insurance yearbook, 2007–2008 (pp. 20–27). Karachi: Author.
Jeng, V., & Lai, G. C. (2005). Ownership structure, agency costs, specialization and efficiency: Analysis of keiretsu and independent insurers in the Japanese nonlife insurance industry. Journal of Risk and Insurance, 72(1), 105–158.
Jeng, V., Lai, G. C., & McNamara, M. J. (2007). Efficiency and demutualization: Evidence from the US life insurance industry in the 1980s and 1990s. Journal of Risk and Insurance, 74(3), 683–711.
Kao, C., & Hwang, S.-N. (2008). Efficiency decomposition in two-stage data envelopment analysis: An application to nonlife insurance companies in Taiwan. European Journal of Operational Research, 185(1), 418–429.
Karim, M. Z., & Jhantasana, C. (2005). Cost efficiency and profitability in Thailand’s life insurance industry: A stochastic cost frontier approach. International Journal of Applied Econometrics and Quantitative Studies, 2, 19–36.
Knox Lovell, C. A. (1993). Production frontiers and productive efficiency. In H. O. Fried, C. A. Knox Lovell & S. S. Schmidt (Eds.), The measurement of productive efficiency: Techniques and applications (pp. 3–67). New York: Oxford University Press.
Mansoor, S. A., & Radam, A. (2000). Productivity and efficiency performance of the Malaysian life insurance industry. Jurnal Ekonomi Malaysia, 34, 93–105.
McIntosh, J. (1998). Scale efficiency in a dynamic model of Canadian insurance companies. Journal of Risk and Insurance, 65(2), 303–317.
Meador, J. W., Ryan, H. E., & Schellhorn, C. D. (1997). Product focus versus diversification: Estimates of X-efficiency for the US life insurance industry (Working Paper No. 97-16). Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania, Wharton Financial Institutions Center.
Noulas, A. G., Lazaradis, J., Hatzigayios, T., & Lyroudi, K. (2001). Nonparametric production frontier approach to the study of efficiency of nonlife insurance companies in Greece. Journal of Financial Management and Analysis, 14, 19–26.
Rees, R., & Kessner, E. (1999). Regulation and efficiency in European insurance markets. Economic Policy, 14(29), 363–397.
Sealey, C. W, & Lindley, J. T. (1977). Inputs, outputs and a theory of production and cost at depository financial institutions. The Journal of Finance, 32(4), 1251–1266.
Seiford, L. M. (1996). Data envelopment analysis: The evolution of the state of the art (1978–1995). Journal of Productivity Analysis, 7(2–3), 99–137.
State Bank of Pakistan. (2005). Developments in the insurance sector. In Pakistan financial sector assessment 2005 (pp. 105–121). Karachi: Author.
State Bank of Pakistan. (2008). Risk assessment of the insurance sector. In Financial Stability Review 2007–08 (pp. 213–225). Karachi: Author.
State Bank of Pakistan. (2010). Financial stability review 2009–10. Karachi: Author.
Swiss Re. (2010). World insurance in 2009: Premiums dipped, but industry capital improved (Sigma No. 2/2010). Zurich: Author.
Worthington, A. C., & Hurley, E. V. (2002). Cost efficiency in Australian general insurers: A nonparametric approach. The British Accounting Review, 34(2), 89–108.
Yuengert, A. M. (1993). The measurement of efficiency in life insurance: Estimates of a mixed normal-gamma error model. Journal of Banking and Finance, 17(2–3), 483–496.
